A piece of early writing 'critiqued' ... note the question marks.

I’ve been haunted today by the ghosts of papers past as I return to the beginning of my thesis to start the inevitable tortuous  re-write.  I am finding it hard to settle down to it. But one inevitability of researching is  exorcising the ghosts of papers past editing your own work. It is probably the most difficult of the entire writing process. I don’t know about you out there, (but I imagine you are not much different to me in this respect), but when I hand over a piece of writing to be reviewed I am damn glad to get shot of it. Usually I am heartily sick of reading it and need to just get it out of my sight. So you can imagine how utterly sickened thrilled   I am when it is returned to me, with orders from El Prima’s ‘suggestions’ for a complete rewrite  improvements.

I found the only way to edit one’s own work is to allow a certain amount of time to elapse before you so much as pick it up again. Preferably you will be able to write something new and fresh in the interim, returning to the original piece of work after several weeks has elapsed. By this time, hopefully, you will have given yourself enough time to become detached from the emotional trauma  intensity of writing it in the first place. When I first started my research I spent an inordinate amount of time editing and re-editing the same exhausted and over written piece of claptrap  few thousand words, in effect getting absolutely no where. I could rarely see what El Prima’s* suggestions meant and even more rarely could I seem to follow them through satisfactorily. Which led to a lot of swearing, screaming and tantrums  frustration on my part and no doubt hers!

My approach has changed dramatically. I now allow several weeks (perhaps months) to pass before I pick up a piece of work that needs serious revision. I am not talking about minor typos and grammatical errors, but pieces where large swathes need to be re-written in order to make the piece work. Usually by the time I return to it I have forgotten the majority of it (think Dory from finding Nemo, me research is basically a metaphorical ‘castle’ in goldfish bowl) and I can review it with fresh eyes and far less emotional attachment . I can also take the textual shredding criticism on the chin without feeling it is entirely personal and aimed at destroying me completely! This makes the process much easier on the psyche. Nevertheless I still feel the battle cry of “Once more unto the breach dear friends” on my lips whenever I know I am returning to the ghosts of papers past!

*El Prima is  my polite version nickname for my primary supervisor. My secondary supervisor is called El Secunda.


4 thoughts on “When the past comes back to haunt you.

  1. I’m also a grad student and stumbled across your blog from blipfoto. I have to admit, it is comforting to know that I’m not the only one who requires a long break from a piece of work to even get back to it without being too nauseated from the first run with it. Gives me some hope that I’m not JUST procrastinating, but there might be a good reason for it…

    1. Nope not procrastination – productive organisation! I get so into my work I cannot see the highs or lows of it. But give me a couple of months and it’s like I’m reading someone else’s work, which is exactly the perspective you need when editing. Say hi and blip and I’ll come visit you over there x x

      1. I agree with your sentiments wholeheartedly. I know that the initial lag (procrastination) is because I hate the task of editing my own work, usually because i think, “did I really write something so silly?”. For me, it is kinda like when I hate to watch videos of myself “is my hair really like that?!”.

        But I definitely see the value in the Dory from finding Nemo moment and feeling like I am reading someone else’s work. Anyways, it was just affirmation that I need to allow this time of letting things sit, stew and marinate before re-editing instead of feeling like I SHOULD be working on it. In other words, I now give myself permission to let it sit (I have several projects in the works I have been feeling guilty about not tending to. That guilt has just been reconceptualized!)! See ya over in blipworld!

  2. Interesting post, I didn’t have enough time to leave my MA Dissertation for more than a couple of days in order to edit it. Now I am reluctant to read it in case I see too much I should have changed. Looking back at undergrad essays is bad enough! Time away from drafts is something I’ll bear in mind when (if) I start my PhD.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s